Livelihoods in Development Displacement - A Reality Check from the Evaluation Record in Asia

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    Abstract

    Development, widely considered a solution to long-term population displacement, can paradoxically create more displacement. This chapter explores this paradox through the lens of evaluation studies. Early evaluation studies identified a gap between country laws, which positioned development displacement and resettlement as a subset of property and expropriation laws, and international policy, which centralized livelihood measures, living standards, and outcomes for people affected. The chapter explores the international policy conceptualization of livelihoods as embedded in a sociocultural context, requiring strategies to recreate livelihoods, monitoring and evaluation (M&E) and their results in terms of livelihood outcomes. It compares international policy perspective and evaluation outcomes with selected evolving Asian country safeguard systems, to examine the extent to which livelihoods are addressed and evaluated. The gap between international and national standards is narrowing, but livelihood measures form the weakest point in many laws concerning land takings. Differences in time frames, focus, mandates, and resources in project preparation and implementation reflect these divergent objectives. Methods for assessing livelihood risk, planning livelihood support, and for M&E of livelihood outcomes, are rare in country frameworks. Some approaches that may provide a way forward in building the knowledge base on livelihood success and sustainability through evaluation at the country level are presented.
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationEvaluation for Agenda 2030: Providing Evidence on Progress and Sustainability
    Editors R van den Berg, I Naidoo & S Tamondong
    Place of PublicationExeter
    PublisherInternational Development Evaluation Association (IDEAS)
    Pages273-289
    Edition1st
    ISBN (Print)9781999932909
    Publication statusPublished - 2017

    Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Livelihoods in Development Displacement - A Reality Check from the Evaluation Record in Asia'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this